MLB at Midseason: Attendance, ABS Data, and Fanatics Fest

The World Cup is entering its final week on American soil. LA28 is 731 days out. And Major League Baseball, despite occupying a quieter register in the national conversation, just finished its first half with more people in seats than a year ago. Three sports calendars are stacked on top of each other right now, and the business signals embedded in each deserve a closer look than the highlight packages will provide.

SBJ's Abe Madkour walked through the midseason state of play on Tuesday's Buzzcast, and the numbers across baseball, the emerging Fanatics economy, and the NHL's back-office infrastructure tell a more interesting story than any single headline captures.

Baseball's Real Competitive Advantage Is Volume

Start with the raw figure Madkour leads with: MLB is tracking toward its fourth consecutive season drawing over 70 million fans. That number warrants repeating not for its impressiveness, but for what it means structurally. No other North American league operates at that volume. The NFL's gate is bounded by 17 home dates per team. The NBA plays 41. Baseball plays 81, across 30 markets, for six months. The sheer surface area of the game — the number of consumer touchpoints, the sponsorship inventory, the local broadcast minutes — is a category unto itself.

Attendance through the All-Star break is up just over 1% from 2025, which reads as modest until you parse the underlying movement. The big gainers are worth understanding on their own terms. The Tampa Bay Rays are up nearly 70% year-over-year, but as Madkour notes, that figure collapses multiple variables: "They went from Steinbrenner Field, the smaller minor league facility, back to Tropicana Field, but they also have the best record in the American League." Venue capacity plus winning is not a surprising combination. The more instructive case may be the White Sox, up more than 35% after three consecutive poor seasons, now sitting in first place — a direct demonstration of what a competitive product does to the gate independent of market size. The Blue Jays (up more than 30%) and the Mariners (up more than 23%) round out the significant gainers.

The attendance leaders — the Dodgers, Padres, Yankees, Blue Jays, and Phillies — are each down slightly from last year, which suggests the ceiling in premium markets is fairly well established. The teams with structural challenges haven't solved them: the Athletics, Marlins, Royals, and Pirates remain at the bottom of the league in overall draws. Kansas City is down nearly 17%, which is notable given the Royals' competitive improvement in recent years suggested some upside at the gate.

The ABS Data Is More Interesting Than the Controversy

The automated ball-and-strike system is in its first full season, and the challenge data through July 9 — reported by SBJ — is genuinely revealing. More than 5,800 challenge attempts have been logged, with 53% resulting in overturns, according to Sports Business Journal's coverage of the midseason ABS numbers. That headline figure is less a verdict on umpires than a reflection of the system's design: the challenge mechanism exists precisely because close pitches are close.

The split between batters (40% overturn rate) and catchers and pitchers (58%) is the more structurally interesting number. Catchers and pitchers live inside the game differently — their spatial intuition about pitch location is built through repetition and preparation in a way that is distinct from a batter processing a pitch in real time. That gap likely reflects information asymmetry more than anything else.

Umpire Derek Thomas holds the lowest overturn rate in the system, per Baseball Almanac's umpire records — meaning his calls are being confirmed by the ABS technology at the highest rate. The aggregate picture that emerges, as Madkour frames it, is actually a defense of the umps: "The ABS system shows just how good these umpires are. Most of the time, they are right on it." That framing runs against the fan narrative that drove the push for automated officiating in the first place, which is at least worth noting.

Seven umpires have accepted buyouts and are set to retire at season's end — a detail that signals the transition is underway regardless of how the ABS data ultimately reads.

National Ratings: The NBC Effect

On the broadcast side, NBC's Sunday Night Baseball is averaging 2.4 million viewers in its first year on the package — up over 40% from what ESPN was generating in the same window last season, per SBJ media reporter Austin Karp. Madkour is careful with the comparison: "Not necessarily always apples to apples, but the numbers are healthy." That caveat matters. Network reach, promotional infrastructure, and scheduling differences between NBC and ESPN complicate direct comparisons. What the number does confirm is that the new rights structure has not produced an audience contraction, which was a genuine concern entering the season.

Fox is averaging 2.2 million viewers for its Saturday prime-time window, up 10% from the same point in 2025. Other packages — ESPN, TBS, MLB Network — are also showing year-over-year gains. The league enters its second half with its media partners in positive territory.

World Cup, Atlanta, and the Weight of History

Argentina and England meet Wednesday in Atlanta for the World Cup semifinal. The rivalry between these two footballing nations is layered in ways that go well beyond tactics — the Falklands War of the 1980s gave a geopolitical valence to what was already an intense sporting contest, and that weight has never fully dissipated. Atlanta authorities are reportedly on high alert, with approximately 75,000 fans in the stadium and an expected even split between the two supporter groups. The proximity — limited segregation in seating — is precisely the condition that makes security planning complex.

Whatever happens on the pitch, the match is functioning as one of the week's primary commercial anchors, which connects directly to what Fanatics is attempting just a few hundred miles north.

Fanatics Fest: The Three-Year Build

Fanatics Fest opens Thursday at the Javits Center in Manhattan, and this is the year Fanatics officials say the event turns a profit. The arc here is worth tracing. The inaugural 2024 event drew 70,000 attendees. Year two reached 120,000. The projection for year three is over 200,000 across four days — a number that, if accurate, would make it one of the larger sports-adjacent consumer events in the country.

The event's expansion into non-endemic sponsorship — American Express, AT&T, Starbucks, PayPal — signals a deliberate pivot from trade-show economics toward something closer to a cultural property. "They really want to drive the social and cultural conversation across a whole week in New York," Madkour says of Fanatics' ambitions. The timing against the World Cup final on Sunday is not accidental; the plan is to use the event's final day as a watch party for the championship match, with the MetLife Stadium final in nearby New Jersey serving as the anchor.

The strategic logic is straightforward: if you can occupy the week when global football reaches its climax on American soil, and position your brand as the gathering point for that energy, you have something that's worth considerably more than a merchandise trade show. Whether Fanatics can sustain the event's growth trajectory past this particular confluence of circumstances — World Cup on the doorstep, summer cultural vacuum, novelty premium — is the question that year four will answer.

NHL's Quieter Signal

In Denver, the NHL's annual club business meetings drew more than 1,300 representatives from all 32 clubs — the largest gathering in the event's 30-year history. Commissioner Gary Bettman and Stan Kroenke are headlining with a fireside chat Wednesday. The agenda covers ticketing, sponsorship, marketing, analytics, and technology. These meetings rarely generate the kind of news that dominates sports media, but record participation from all 32 clubs in a 30-year-old event is, by itself, a data point about organizational health and league cohesion.

---

Madkour closes with a note that cuts through the positive half-year data for baseball: as the season progresses, labor negotiations and the possibility of a work stoppage will increasingly dominate the conversation. That context reframes everything above. Attendance trends, broadcast gains, ABS adoption — all of it is being evaluated against a CBA backdrop that could, if it breaks badly, make the second-half numbers irrelevant. The sport's structural momentum is genuine. Whether it survives the next negotiating table is the question that follows every other number home.

— Marcus Tate, Sports Desk Editor